Welcome to Nantuckets
Nestled in the picturesque Port Jefferson, NY, Nantuckets embodies the charm of coastal dining. With a delightful outdoor deck that features live saxophone music, patrons experience memorable evenings paired with expertly crafted dishes. Highlights include the renowned buttered lobster roll, succulent crab cakes, and meticulously prepared fillet mignon, all complemented by warm, attentive service. The visually appealing atmosphere, enhanced by a cozy fireplace, invites guests to linger and savor their meals. Whether indulging in unique brunch offerings or elegant dinners, Nantuckets promises generous portions and a vibrant culinary experience that keeps diners returning.
-
9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, United States Hotline: +1 631-509-4848
Welcome to Nantuckets, a charming gem located at 9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson, NY 11777. This restaurant promises more than just a meal; it offers an experience wrapped in delightful ambiance, attentive service, and, most importantly, incredible food.
Picture enjoying a scrumptious dinner on their outdoor deck, serenaded by live saxophone music, while the sun sets over the harbor. It’s a scene that captures the essence of Nantuckets, as described by customer Kim Tedesco, who fondly reminisced about their Friday night dinner as a memorable highlight. The moment you step in, it’s clear that owner Richie knows exactly what it takes to create not only an enjoyable dining atmosphere but also fosters a community feeling among guests.
Nantuckets’ menu is a testament to the culinary talents of its kitchen. From the moment you take your first bite, like the buttered lobster roll praised by Jeffrey Feuer, you understand that quality ingredients and meticulous preparation are paramount here. The crab cakes, highlighted by multiple patrons, are reputedly loaded with crab and topped with a delightful Aioli sauce, proving to be a standout starter that sets the tone for an impeccable meal.
For those celebrating a special occasion, like Steven Cardillo did on New Year's Eve, Nantuckets offers a special menu that tantalizes the taste buds. His experience featured a fillet mignon paired beautifully with a lobster tail, exquisitely seasoned to elevate the dish, reinforcing the belief that local seafood and expert cooking go hand in hand. And let’s not forget their desserts. The Creme Brulee, coupled with fresh whipped cream, makes for a perfect ending to a night of indulgence.
One of the things that stand out besides the food is the excellent service. Diners have shared praise for the friendly and accommodating staff, as reflected in Ryan O’s delightful outdoor dining experience. With a perfectly crafted martini in hand and a view of the serene harbor, it’s hard not to appreciate the thoughtful attention each guest receives.
In addition to its stellar entrees, Nantuckets offers various brunch options that have also captivated locals. With dishes like truffle parmesan fries and French toast bites, every plate is designed to please. Customer Mary Elizabeth echoes this sentiment, recommending the generous portions that leave diners both satisfied and ready to return.
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, Nantuckets provides a delightful blend of atmosphere, service, and exceptional cuisine. As you savor each bite, the heart and soul poured into this establishment become evident. For anyone looking to explore the culinary landscape of Port Jefferson, Nantuckets should undeniably sit atop your must-visit list.
Enjoyed a delicious Friday night dinner (6/6/25) on Nantucket’s outdoor deck while being serenaded by live saxophone music - made for a very pleasant and memorable evening. Will definitely return.
Went New Year’s Eve had an awesome meal off their special menu. Started off with a nice glass of German resiling wine, Shades of Blue, excellent! Then for appetizer had the crab cakes, loaded with crab topped with Aioli sauce, best I’ve ever had. Then had the fillet mignon with lobster tail, fillet had a good amount of gristle in the middle that I had to work around, other than that it was very good. Lobster tail was presented and seasoned very well in some sort of marinated butter, wine and garlic which I thought was top notch of flavor and tenderness. Came with the mash potatoes another good choice some of the best made. I can’t forget their delicious homemade multi grain bread which was very good. For last desert opted for the Creme Brulee topped off with fresh made whipped cream, awesome. Let me also mention about our waitress very friendly and accommodating, great customer service. Overall had a very enjoyable and unforgettable experience at Nantucket's other than the fillet not being completely satisfied I give it the Cardillo Scale Rating Review of 4.8 out of 5. Will definitely be back again. Happy New Year
We decided to try Nantuckets and we decided it is our new goto in port Jefferson. BEST buttered lobster roll we ever had. The salmon was cooked and seasoned to perfection. And oh yes the stacked tuna appetizer was perfect. The staff was great... attentive, but not too, and very friendly (Skylar). The place was redone about a year ago and looks great. I highly recommend this restaurant
Random pick from Google Maps was a gem. Enjoyed a fine meal, in a nice dining room. Quite lively as we sat down with a full room, but we were late and enjoyed a quiet dessert conversation. Would go back.
Super adorable little spot in Port Jeff. The food is great, pricing isn't bad and you get plenty of food. The service is slow but I think they want you to slow down and enjoy life. The drinks are also very yummy. We tried the French toast bites which I highly recommend and the eggs any style plate with parm truffle fries instead of home fries. I will say they do not skimp on the ingredients the parm truffle fries were delicious even for brunch. For drinks we tried bellini's, espresso martini and mango jalapeno margaritas all were made amazingly. Would definitely go here and again and we did recommend it to anyone we knew. We even ran into a friend dining here with family. We were all from out of town visiting for a wedding.
Walking in, it's so obvious that you're not only gonna have a great meal, but you're gonna have a great time. The proprietor, Richie, has paid attention to what he knows best; HOW TO RUN A RESTAURANT. It's lovely inside and beautifully appointed. But let's get to the food! The good tastes just as good as the place looks. FANTASTIC. I've been several times. My fave were the lollipop lambchops. Also enjoyed every fish selection on the menus. Great drinks. AND, Last but not least, is that the food is piping hot. That is important to me. Do if you're looking for a great place to go for dinner in Port Jefferson, dine here. Oh! You can eat in the main dining room and see the harbor, or, sit in the smaller room where the bar is located. There is a FIREPLACE that you can sit next to. Just do it!!
Excellent outdoor dining experience! The staff was very friendly and attentive. We had martinis and the crab cake (Hands down the best I've had!) while sitting on the patio. Highly recommended!
everything at brunch was delicious & perfectly cooked. they raised prices recently but the portions are generous, which I appreciate (some restaurants both raise prices & reduce portions which isn’t cool). you will leave full & very satisfied.